Herbartian Approach Models of Lesson Planning – Meaning, Steps, Merits & Limitations

Herbartian Approach Models of Lesson Planning – Meaning, Steps, Merits & Limitations

Introduction

Lesson planning is the backbone of effective teaching. A well-planned lesson ensures clarity of objectives, systematic presentation of content, and meaningful learning outcomes. Over time, various models of lesson planning have been developed, among which the Herbartian Approach holds a significant place in the history of education.

The Herbartian Model of Lesson Planning is based on the ideas of Johann Friedrich Herbart (1776–1841), a German philosopher and psychologist. This model emphasizes logical sequencing of content, mental preparation of learners, and clear presentation of knowledge. Though considered traditional, it continues to be an important topic in teacher education programmes and competitive examinations.

Meaning of Herbartian Approach

The Herbartian Approach refers to a teacher-centred, content-oriented model of lesson planning that focuses on systematic instruction and intellectual development of students. It is grounded in association psychology, which believes that new knowledge is best learned by relating it to previous knowledge.

According to Herbart, teaching should proceed in logical and sequential steps so that learners can easily understand, retain, and apply knowledge. The approach mainly emphasizes knowledge acquisition, rather than skill development or creativity.

Philosophy Behind the Herbartian Approach

The Herbartian model is based on the following philosophical assumptions:

  1. Mind is a storehouse of ideas

  2. Learning occurs through association of ideas

  3. Teaching should be planned, organized, and systematic

  4. Teacher plays a central role in the teaching-learning process

  5. Education aims at intellectual development and character formation

Herbartian Approach Models of Lesson Planning – Meaning, Steps, Merits & Limitations

Principles of the Herbartian Approach

The Herbartian lesson planning model is based on the following principles:

1. Principle of Correlation

New knowledge should be linked with learners’ previous knowledge.

2. Principle of Psychological Sequencing

Teaching should proceed from known to unknown, simple to complex, and concrete to abstract.

3. Principle of Interest

Students’ interest should be aroused through proper motivation and presentation.

4. Principle of Logical Presentation

Subject matter should be arranged in a logical and systematic manner.

5. Principle of Reinforcement

Learning should be reinforced through repetition and application.

Steps / Models of Herbartian Lesson Planning

The classical Herbartian approach consists of five formal steps, also known as Herbartian Models of Lesson Planning.

1. Preparation

Meaning

Preparation is the first step of the Herbartian lesson plan. It aims to prepare the mental state of students for learning new knowledge.

Objectives

  • To test previous knowledge

  • To arouse curiosity and interest

  • To establish a link between old and new knowledge

Role of Teacher

  • Ask introductory questions

  • Recall previous lessons

  • Create a learning atmosphere

Example

Before teaching “Evaporation,” the teacher asks students about drying clothes in sunlight.

2. Presentation

Meaning

Presentation refers to the systematic presentation of new content to students.

Objectives

  • To introduce new ideas clearly

  • To explain concepts step by step

  • To use appropriate teaching aids

Role of Teacher

  • Explain concepts using examples

  • Use blackboard, charts, or models

  • Maintain clarity and accuracy

Role of Students

  • Listen attentively

  • Observe and understand

3. Association (Comparison)

Meaning

Association involves comparing new knowledge with previous knowledge to form mental connections.

Objectives

  • To deepen understanding

  • To highlight similarities and differences

  • To strengthen retention

Teaching Techniques Used

  • Question–answer method

  • Comparison and contrast

  • Examples and counter-examples

Importance

This step ensures meaningful learning by integrating old and new ideas.

4. Generalization

Meaning

Generalization is the process of deriving general rules, principles, or definitions from specific examples.

Objectives

  • To formulate laws or principles

  • To ensure conceptual clarity

  • To promote logical thinking

Example

After several examples, students derive the definition of evaporation.

5. Application

Meaning

Application refers to using acquired knowledge in new situations.

Objectives

  • To test understanding

  • To transfer learning

  • To reinforce concepts

Methods

  • Numerical problems

  • Practical examples

  • Real-life situations

Importance

This step ensures that learning is functional and permanent.

Role of Teacher in Herbartian Lesson Planning

  • Planner and organizer

  • Knowledge provider

  • Classroom controller

  • Evaluator of learning

The teacher dominates the teaching-learning process in this model.

Role of Learner in Herbartian Approach

  • Passive listener

  • Receiver of knowledge

  • Responds to teacher’s questions

Learners have limited scope for creativity and independent thinking.

Merits of Herbartian Approach

  1. Systematic and well-organized lesson structure

  2. Suitable for theoretical subjects

  3. Easy to plan and implement

  4. Useful for beginner teachers

  5. Ensures logical presentation of content

  6. Helpful in exam-oriented teaching

Limitations of Herbartian Approach

  1. Teacher-centred approach

  2. Neglects individual differences

  3. Little scope for creativity and critical thinking

  4. Learners remain passive

  5. Not suitable for skill-based subjects

  6. Ignores modern constructivist views of learning

Relevance of Herbartian Approach in Modern Education

Although modern pedagogy emphasizes learner-centred approaches, the Herbartian model is still relevant:

  • Useful for introductory lessons

  • Effective for conceptual clarity

  • Helpful in large classrooms

  • Still included in teacher education syllabi

Comparison with Modern Lesson Planning Models

BasisHerbartian ModelModern Models
NatureTeacher-centredLearner-centred
FocusKnowledgeSkills & understanding
MethodLecture & Q/AActivity-based
FlexibilityRigidFlexible

Conclusion

The Herbartian Approach Models of Lesson Planning represent a classical and systematic method of teaching that laid the foundation for modern lesson planning techniques. Despite its limitations, the approach remains significant in understanding the evolution of teaching methods and continues to be relevant in examination contexts.

For teachers and teacher-trainees, mastering the Herbartian lesson planning model helps in developing structured teaching skills, especially during the initial stages of professional growth.


Discover more from YOUR SMART CLASS

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top

Discover more from YOUR SMART CLASS

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading